Harry Potter

I’m not going to talk about American Idol today because I didn’t like the show last night at all.  I didn’t think anyone sounded very good and I was nearly blinded several times by Paula’s plunging neckline, which left me feeling uncomfortable and nervous for her.  The only thing I liked was Allison’s hair.  It was rockin’…

I will tell you, however, that I finally finished the Harry Potter series.  I know I’m a couple years late on this, but I have to say that those books were brilliant.  Brilliant as in that may be the best series of our generation.  I am actually a little sad today that it’s over.  I miss Harry, Ron and Hermione.  The story was written so well that I actually felt I was a part of that world when I read the books and when I closed book 7 last night, I felt a pang of regret that it was over.

I must admit that I was one of those people who did not read the books because of the witchcraft aspect of the storyline.  I bought the whole idea of them being evil hook, line and sinker.  But, I was wrong.

Yes, the books center on young witches and wizards in training and I don’t diminish the fact that we have to be careful how closely we tread to such practices, but the storyline of Harry Potter is complete fantasy.  It’s the folklore surrounding witchcraft that makes up the story, but the theme is good verses evil and the power of love to conquer evil.  In fact, after awhile, the magical part of the books became just a back story.  I was more enraptured with the characters – with Harry’s reconciliation with the death of his parents; with Ron and Hermione’s obvious attraction; with Dumbledore’s wisdom on life, love and peace; with Fred and George’s ability to find the humor in any situation, no matter how bleak.  Those were the things that stood out to me.  The magic just faded into the background.

In fact, book 7 is ripe with Christian imagery and from the research that I’ve done on J.K. Rowling, that was intentional.  I was pleasantly surprised by this fact. 

Rowling does not practice witchcraft, as was widely circulated among Christian circles.  She simply had a story to tell.  And, we must remember that Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings and C.S. Lewis’s Chronicles of Narnia also involved witches, wizards and magic as a means to tell a story.  Gandolf was a good wizard, much along the lines of a Dumbledore.  The White Witch in Chronicles was evil, much along the lines of Voldemort or Bellatrix Lestrange.

I do not think that the Potter series is as rich in imagery as Lord of the Rings or Chronicles, but in ranking those three series, I would place Rowling’s books third on the list.  It’s that good.

I don’t think that I would read these books to my kids, however, for several reasons.  First, there are over 4,000 pages to read and my kids can hardly sit still for a short picture book.  Second, there are themes within those books that I think are far too mature for young children.  I won’t even show them the movies for that reason alone.  The story is fantastic, but it is dark and I just don’t think my kids are ready to process the messages and images presented at such a young age.  I also won’t allow them see Lord of the Rings for the very same reason.  It’s too dark and too scary.

When they get older, I will be happy to let them begin reading these stories and possibly see the movies if they’re even interested by then.  But before then, in my opinion, these books are a little too much.

It is my hope that my children will one day have an appreciation for good literature and good story telling.  I hope they will consume books and fall in love with the characters.  Harry Potter is an easy character to fall in love with and at the end, his story is redemptive. 

Now I am going to take a break and catch up on sleep because I am just exhausted.

Comments

  1. It is such a great series I am so glad that you decided to read it!! I totally agree with you on the book being about good vs evil and true friendship. I absolutely LOVE the Weasleys and how JK Rowling wrapped everything up at the end.
    I don’t know about you but my heart starting aching at the end of book 6 when everything happened with Dumbledore and Snape. Then when I found out how Snape really felt about Harry all these years, oh I didn’t think I could handle anymore. Then she goes and well you know what happened to the Weasley family (just in case someone out there hasn’t read it yet and now wants to) and how she ended the book with the last chapter being about the future LOVED LOVED LOVED it, that may have been one of my absolute favorite parts of the whole story even though I could barely read the words because my eyes were totally blurred with tears. Oh what a GREAT series!!

  2. ah..duh..drool drool.(spoken like Patrick from Spongebob) did someone say read a book???? I did WATCH the Harry Potter series, does that count?? I am glad I am not one of your offspring Kelli, you would be dreadfully disappointed in me. I’d much rather pop a DVD in than read a book:(

  3. Megan P. says

    Let this be a lesson to Christians that we have to do our own research instead of relying on what “they” say. It’s frustrating when people just take things as fact without finding answers for themselves. So many things go undone or get misunderstood because of holier than thou people speaking before they think. So glad you enjoyed the series!!
    Megan
    (friend of Nicole D.)

  4. I just picked the first book up at a yard sale this weekend for 25 cents! 🙂 And finally… I’m going to see what the rest of the world has been telling me I’ve been missing. 🙂 After reading your post, I can’t wait.

  5. There’s something about epic storytelling that seems to strike a chord in our hearts and minds. I think that a major part of that comes from the most EPIC of all stories….The Holy Bible.

    I can’t say that I have ever entertained the thought of reading any of the Harry Potter series, but maybe you might make a believer out of me yet. It seems like my ability to devour books has been stymied by the inner turmoil that has consumed my head. This too shall pass, and soon.

    Maybe once your brain has calmed a little more you can give The Dark Tower a chance. It’s a tough read, I won’t lie. Mr. King does not hold back like the lady Rowling may have, but he does it just as good. I miss the Ka-Tet (you’ll find out) of Roland, Eddie, Susannah, Jake and the faithful Oy. I wonder where they are, and if they are okay.

    It’s amazing that silly little daydreams of average people can consume us and make us feel like we are a part of their imaginations. I’ve always wanted to write something that HUGE and expansive but I can’t even finish a 90 screenplay. We need to workshop very soon! I love you sis!